We confirmed that you could probably save money by using more than one price comparison site for car insurance.
Advertisements suggest that particular price comparison sites provide the cheapest results for everyone. This is simply not true.
Our test results suggest that most people could save money by getting multiple price comparisons, rather than relying on just one. According to these results, more than 90% of motorists would have achieved a saving, varying from as little as 11p right up to £750.78, with an average of £123.99, just by getting quotes from several price comparison sites, rather than just one.
There are some caveats, however. On the day that we conducted the tests, anyone else using the same criteria should have received similar results. We cannot be sure of this, though, since it is always possible that insurers, like many other high-tech companies, use personalised results, or geo-location to help them decide which data set to display.
It is also very difficult to produce a completely 'typical' set of criteria for the applicants so it is highly likely that another similar sized survey would produce a different set of results. We are sure, however, that the basic conclusion will be the same; that the majority of people searching for the cheapest car insurance could make considerable savings by spending an extra half an hour or so checking all the major price comparison sites, rather than just one.
So far we have not looked into the effects of accidents or convictions on quotations. This is an area that we shall do more research into.
In short, we have not proven that any price comparison engine is any better, or any worse, than any other one. We will need considerably more data to do that. We have, however, made a start. We will build on that in the future, so stay tuned.
We have conducted hundreds of tests to find the cheapest insurance.
How we conducted the tests Table of results
Do you have any suggestions about how we can improve these tests? Then please contact us
Copyright © 2018 Prudent Plus Ltd All Rights Reserved
verycheapcarinsurance.uk is a trading style of Prudent Plus Ltd of Booths Hall, Booths Park, Chelford Road Knutsford WA16 8GS. Our company is registered in England no. 10104295.
We are registered with the Financial Conduct Authority; reference number: 765239
Our opening hours are: Monday to Thursday 9.00am to 6.00pm; Friday, 9.00am to 5.00pm; Saturday 9.00am to 12.30pm. Closed Sundays.
However; our website is open 24 hours a day, 365 days a week (we give it a day off every leap year)!
We do not give financial advice on this website. If in doubt get professional advice and always read the policy information before purchasing an insurance contract.